Monday, May 23, 2011

Television's Impact on Organ Donations



The beginnings of television(TV) were in 1927 when Philo Farnsworth was able to transmit an electronic picture of a dollar sign. It was another twelve years before there was a public demonstration of a TV broadcast system at the world fair. According to class notes an analog TV set consists of a cathode ray tube(CRT) and an electron gun. The CRT is a near vacuum tube with a florescent screen. The electron gun sits at the back of the CRT and shoots three beams(red, green, and blue) which creates an image one line at a time. Analog TV is now almost completely replaced by digital television(DTV). The FCC defines DTV as any technology that uses digital techniques to provide advanced television services such as HDTV, multiple definition standard TV, and any other features and services. There are many reasons that make DTV better than analong TV including a wider image, better picture quality, better sound quality, and video multicasting(video multicasting allows for multiple video signals to be sent out on one TV channel).
 

Television has had a tremendous effect on how Americans view and act on various issues. One example of this is how television shows impact whether people will become an organ donor or not. There is an extreme need in the United States for organ transplants, but the availability of those willing to donate can not keep up with the need. In a study by Morgan at Purdue University(2009) participants completed a survey after watching one of six different episodes that falsely depicted the organ transplant process. This study used episodes from Grey's Anatomy, House, CSI:NY, and Numb3rs. There are many other popular shows that have been used in other studies such as ER, NCIS, The Unit, Law and Order, and Ghost Whisperer(Morgan 2010). There are an abundance of television shows that Americans can watch that depict black markets, murders to gain organs, and priority given to certain people, none of which are true. Very few Americans know anything about the organ donation process past the knowledge that there is a need and they can become a donor at the DMV. The hypothesis was that people would believe what is depicted in the different television shows and that this would decrease the chances of them becoming organ donors. The results showed that those who were not already organ donors were less likely to agree to donate organs after watching one of these television episodes, but that those who are already organ donors were not affected by the television shows. Television shows are impacting the number of potential organ donors by falsely depicting how the process occurs.

Morgan, S., Movius, L., & Cody, M. (2009). The power of narratives: the effect of entertainment television organ donation storylines on the attitudes, knowledge, and behaviors of donor and nondonors. Journal of Communication. 59, 135-151.

Morgan, S., et al. (2010). A kernel of truth? the impact of television storylines exploiting myths about organ donation on the public's willingness to donate. Journal of Communication. 60, 778-796.

 

become an organ donor

6 comments:

  1. I found this very interesting. I would not have realized that these shows would turn so many people away from becoming organ donors. But I can see now how that can be true. TV can manipulate people in so many ways just like this. We think things are true just because we see them in shows on TV, yet we never take the time to do research and find out what the true is. Television can sway people so easily because people are addicted to watching it and people want to believe that what they hear out of the TV is always true, especially with their favorite show. Most TV shows especially some reality shows can actually be scripted so it isn't even true, what is going on! I think this is something that needs to change with TV.

    knabe.10@buckeyemail.osu.edu

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hannah,
    Great job on your blog! It was so insightful and interesting; I never even thought about how television and television shows affects organ donations. After reading your blog, I can totally see how shows would affect organ donating. Some people think that television shows that take place in hospitals are really accurate in how hospitals operate. Perhaps disclaimers should be shown before and after a show is aired to tell the viewer that the show is fictional and the events are not real. On the other hand, I often see a lot of organ donating commercials. It would be great if those commercials would counter the “facts” shown on hospital television dramas so that the television audience knows the accurate side in organ donation.

    butler.644

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree that this topic is really interesting. I have seen many of the television shows that you're talking about and I never really thought about how they could affect people's choices in that way. You would think that after some of the ridiculously fictional things that have happened in some of these hospital drama shows people would realize that they can't rely on them to express the truths of real life situations. However, I can also see how they could subliminally alter people's opinions without them realizing. If people didn't know anything about the topic beforehand and they see these TV shows it could just creep into their minds. TV shows should definitely be more careful about how they portray certain things because most of our minds are so impressionable, but that probably won't happen because it would take away from the drama of the shows.

    maher.101

    ReplyDelete
  5. Before I read this blog I had never thought about how TV shows can impact the way people feel about being an organ donor! TV definitely manipulates people in to believing things that a very unrealistic. People get hooked on a television series and want to believe that it’s real life. Some people may watch a TV show and think that they are going to be an organ donor because it can save someone’s life. Another person may watch that same TV show and be freaked out with how they go about the process of using an organ donor. I think that TV shows should start persuading viewers to be organ donors by showing how the process really occurs.

    apking.6

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with this post. I have seen some of these shows and have noticed that they falsely identify the things they do. I have been an organ donor since I turned 16 and my views have not changed. I understand the need for organ donors and shows like these shouldn't change a persons mind on what they want to do. Others that aren't donors and want to be should look into it somewhere else besides television shows so they can get an accurate assumption. TV does a very good job of showing things that are most of the time not true and in this case very far off from being close.
    morgan.886

    ReplyDelete